--- title: 6th Circuit Bankruptcy Judge Whipple Applies Brunner Test to Discharge Student Loan Debt of Functionally Illiterate Debtor description: Read this blog to learn more about the case. image: https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/hubfs/38970275_s.jpg --- [![Goosman Lawfirm](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Goosmannlaw%20October2017/images/Goosmann_Law_Firm_logo_4C-white.png?width=1250&name=Goosmann_Law_Firm_logo_4C-white.png "Goosman Lawfirm")](http://goosmannlaw.com/) - [COVID-19 Toolbox](https://goosmannlaw.com/covid-19-resource-toolbox/) - Our Team - [Attorneys](https://goosmannlaw.com/attorneys/) - [Non-Attorney Staff](https://http://goosmannlaw.com/non-attorney-staff/) - Practices & Industries - [Practices](https://goosmannlaw.com/practices/) - [Banking & Finance](https://goosmannlaw.com/banking-finance/) - [Bankruptcy, Restructuring & Workouts](https://goosmannlaw.com/bankruptcy-restructuring-workouts/) - [Business](https://goosmannlaw.com/business/) - [Divorce & Family Law](https://goosmannlaw.com/divorce-family-law/) - [Employment](https://goosmannlaw.com/employment-law/) - [Environmental, Health & Safety](https://goosmannlaw.com/health-safety/) - [Estate Planning](https://trustlawcounsel.com) - [Gestational Surrogacy & Adoption](https://goosmannlaw.com/gestational-surrogacy-adoption/) - [International Law](http://goosmannlaw.com/international-law/) - [Litigation / Trial Law](https://goosmannlaw.com/litigation-trial-law/) - [Local Counsel](https://http://goosmannlaw.com/local-counsel/) - [Mergers & Acquisitions](https://goosmannlaw.com/mergers-acquisitions/) - [Rapid Response](https://goosmannlaw.com/rapid-response/) - [Industries](https://goosmannlaw.com/industries/) - [Agribusiness & Cooperatives](https://goosmannlaw.com/agribusiness-cooperatives/) - [Construction](https://goosmannlaw.com/construction/) - [Cyber Law and Telecommunications](https://goosmannlaw.com/cyber-law/) - [Education](https://goosmannlaw.com/education/) - [Health Care](https://goosmannlaw.com/health-care/) - [Manufacturing](https://goosmannlaw.com/manufacturing-law/) - [Multifamily Housing](https://goosmannlaw.com/multifamily-housing-law/) - [Non-Profit & Tax Exempt Organizations](https://goosmannlaw.com/non-profit-law/) - [Real Estate](https://goosmannlaw.com/real-estate/) - [Transportation](https://goosmannlaw.com/transportation/) - [Tribal](https://goosmannlaw.com/tribal/) - Our Firm - [Firm News](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/firm-news) - Careers - [Attorneys](https://goosmannlaw.com/careers/attorneys/) - [Administration](https://goosmannlaw.com/careers/administration/) - [Internships](https://goosmannlaw.com/careers/internships/) - [Client Testimonials and Results](https://goosmannlaw.com/our-firm/client-testimonials-and-results/) - [Culture, Diversity, and Community](https://http://goosmannlaw.com/our-firm/culture-diversity-and-community/) - [Women-Owned Business](https://goosmannlaw.com/our-firm/women-owned-business/) - [Associations & Memberships](https://goosmannlaw.com/associations-memberships/) - [Firm History](https://goosmannlaw.com/firm-history/) - Blogs - [CEO Law Review](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/ceo-on-your-side) - [Construction Lawyer](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/construction-lawyer-on-your-side) - [Cyber Lawyer](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/cyber-lawyer-on-your-side) - [Deal Maker](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/deal-maker-on-your-side) - [Divorce Docket](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/divorce-lawyer-on-your-side) - [Food for Thought](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/agricultural-lawyer-on-your-side) - [HR Legal Insider](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/human-resources-on-your-side) - [Law Doc](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/health-lawyer-on-your-side) - [Paralegal Review](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/paralegal-review/) - [Real Estate Lawyer](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/real-estate-lawyer-on-your-side) - [Risky Business](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/risk-manager-on-your-side) - [The Banker’s Suit](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side) - [Trial Law Review](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/trial-lawyer-on-you-side) - [Trust Law Counsel](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/estate-planning-laywer-on-your-side) - Resources - [COVID-19 Resource Toolbox](https://goosmannlaw.com/covid-19-resource-toolbox/) - [Podcast](http://podcast.goosmannlaw.com/) - [Videos](https://goosmannlaw.com/videos/) - [FREE eBooks & Tools](https://goosmannlaw.com/free-ebooks-tools/) - Contact Us - [Office Locations](https://goosmannlaw.com/locations/) - [Sioux City Law Firm](https://goosmannlaw.com/locations/sioux-city-law-firm/) - [Sioux Falls Law Firm](https://goosmannlaw.com/locations/sioux-falls-law-firm/) - [Omaha Law Firm](https://goosmannlaw.com/locations/omaha-law-firm/) - [Spirit Lake & Spencer Law Firms](https://goosmannlaw.com/locations/spirit-lake-and-spencer-law-firm/) - [Real Estate Closings Office](https://goosmannlaw.com/locations/real-estate-closing-office/) - [Submit a Testimonial](https://goosmannlaw.com/submit-a-testimonial/) - [Sign Up for Our Newsletter](https://goosmannlaw.com/sign-up-for-our-newsletter/) - [Pay Online](https://goosmannlaw.com/pay-online-3/) - [  (855) 843-4531](tel:855-843-4531) ![](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/hubfs/Blog_Images/Lockbox%20Lawyer/close-button.png) [tel:855-THE-GLF1](tel:855-THE-GLF1) # [6th Circuit Bankruptcy Judge Whipple Applies Brunner Test to Discharge Student Loan Debt of Functionally Illiterate Debtor](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor) By [Elizabeth M. Lally](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/author/elizabeth-m-lally)   |  1, November 2018 [READ NOW](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor) [Read Post](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#article) [![](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Elizabeth%20M%20Lally%20Headshot_Close-2.jpg?width=60&name=Elizabeth%20M%20Lally%20Headshot_Close-2.jpg)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/author/elizabeth-m-lally) [Elizabeth M. Lally](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/author/elizabeth-m-lally) I have written before about the mounting student loan debt problem in America and the challenges this problem presents Debtors and lenders under the current Bankruptcy Code.  In *In Re Pierson* [\[1\]](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#_ftn1) Judge Mary Ann Whipple of the 6th Circuit (Toledo, Ohio) held that eligibility for an income-based repayment (“IBR”) program *does not* preclude a debtor from discharging student loans, especially when a debtor is living below the poverty line. In her opinion, Judge Whipple rejects most of the arguments lenders have been making in similar student debt discharge cases concerning a debtor’s general “ability” to make IBRs. In *Pierson*, the functionally illiterate Debtor had incurred $15,000 in student loans from 1996-1997 while studying car mechanics. He did not graduate, and he did not work as a mechanic. The Debtor suffered from bipolar disorder and had spent part of his life living out of a car. Employed part time, he earned about $14,000 a year, which Judge Whipple described as “living in poverty.” His wife earned about $230 a month cleaning houses. The Debtor, his wife, and his teenage step-daughter lived in a mobile home that lacked both a furnace and an operable stove. Despite these circumstances, the 47-year-old Debtor was eligible for an IBR program where he would not be required to make payments toward his student loans given his income, and, assuming his income did not rise, his loans would be forgiven in about 22 years. The student loan debt forgiveness, however, might become taxable income. The Sixth Circuit has adopted the *Brunner* test  to evaluate whether a debtor has shown an undue hardship and, therefore, that the debtor’s student loans are dischargeable under Section 523(a)(8) of the Bankruptcy Code.[\[2\]](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#_ftn2) Specifically, the *Brunner* test requires a showing that: (1) the debtor cannot maintain, based on current income and expenses, a “minimal” standard of living for the debtor and the debtor’s dependents if forced to repay the student loans; (2) additional circumstances exist indicating that this state of affairs is likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period of the student loans; and (3) the debtor has made good faith efforts to repay the loans.[\[3\]](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#_ftn3) Because the Debtor could pay nothing under an IBR program, the lender argued the student loans imposed no undue hardship under the first prong of Brunner because no payment was required. Judge Whipple observed, however, that the IBR program is “neither automatic nor permanent” but requires continual reapplication, which could be beyond the capacity of some debtors.  While citing to cases that have come down on both sides of this fence, Judge Whipple reasoned that if eligibility for the program precluded the discharge of student loans “the hardship discharge provision for student loans would be effectively eliminated for those most likely to be entitled to it.” Accordingly, Judge Whipple concluded that the Debtor satisfied the first prong of the *Brunner* test, even though he was eligible to pay nothing. As to the second and third prongs, the lender argued that the Debtor should move to another town in pursuit of higher income. Judge Whipple rejected this argument, noting the Debtor’s statement that he would lose his wife if he moved, and that the Debtor’s “support system” was in Toledo, where he lived. Judge Whipple concluded that the Debtor was “not acting unreasonably or unfairly to his student loan holder by continuing to make and try to build a life in Toledo.” Additionally, Judge Whipple noted if he were to obtain a second part-time job, his poverty would continue because the increased income would end his eligibility for food stamps and leave him with no more net disposable income. Further, Judge Whipple noted that the Debtor had shown good faith by having made some payments on the loans, although the payments were never enough to reduce principal. She also found an additional basis for finding good faith in that *the Debtor’s student loans were not the precipitating factor in the debtor’s decision to file bankruptcy*. Rather, the Debtor had been saddled with an $8,000 judgment in favor of a former landlord who was garnishing his wages. Judge Whipple found, therefore, that the Debtor met the second and third parts of the Brunner test, requiring a showing of a good faith attempt to repay the student loans and a demonstration that his circumstances were likely to persist. *In Re Pierson*  is just one more example of how America’s bankruptcy judges are continuing to rebuke lender’s arguments and discharge student loan debts.  [![CONTACT US](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/489404/60d77596-fa6c-4cb1-a3bf-b2fb87ab9210.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/489404/60d77596-fa6c-4cb1-a3bf-b2fb87ab9210) [\[1\]](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#_ftnref1) *Pierson v. Educational Credit Management Corp*. (In re Pierson), 17-3096 (Bankr. N.D. Ohio Oct. 4, 2018) [\[2\]](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#_ftnref2)  *Barrett v. Educational Credit Management Corp*., 487 F.3d 353 (6th Cir. 2007). [\[3\]](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/6th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-whipple-applies-brunner-test-to-discharge-student-loan-debt-of-functionally-illiterate-debtor#_ftnref3) *Brunner v. New York State Higher Educ. Servs. Corp.*, 831 F. 2d 395 (2d Cir. 1987). ### Select Different CTA for each Post from Blog Editor [![New Call-to-action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/489404/a8cefc17-3b9d-4de0-89cd-e60a64752422.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/489404/a8cefc17-3b9d-4de0-89cd-e60a64752422) ### Subscribe Our Blog Thanks for submission!! - Recent - Popular ### Posts by Topic - [Banking (34)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/banking) - [Bankruptcy (26)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/bankruptcy) - [COVID-19 (15)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/covid-19) - [Banking Litigation (12)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/banking-litigation) - [Chapter 11 Bankruptcy (12)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/chapter-11-bankruptcy) - [Subchapter V (9)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/subchapter-v) - [Bankruptcy Court (6)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/bankruptcy-court) - [Student Loan Debt (3)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/student-loan-debt) - [Foreclosure (2)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/foreclosure) - [PPP Loans (2)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/ppp-loans) - [Small Business Owner (2)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/small-business-owner) - [small business (2)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/small-business) - [Agricultural News and Insights (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/agricultural-news-and-insights) - [BNPL (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/bnpl) - [Business Law (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/business-law) - [CARES Act (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/cares-act) - [Chapter 7 Bankruptcy (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/chapter-7-bankruptcy) - [Creditor (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/creditor) - [Cryptocurrency (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/cryptocurrency) - [Deal Gone Bad (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/deal-gone-bad) - [Farm Bankruptcies (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/farm-bankruptcies) - [Farm Forecast (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/farm-forecast) - [Forbearance (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/forbearance) - [Franchise (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/franchise) - [Intellectual Property (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/intellectual-property) - [Judgment (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/judgment) - [Lenders (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/lenders) - [Social Security Benefits (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/social-security-benefits) - [Unpaid Legal Bills (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/unpaid-legal-bills) - [commerical real estate (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/commerical-real-estate) - [evictions (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/evictions) - [liquidation (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/liquidation) - [omaha law firm (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/omaha-law-firm) - [online purchasing (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/online-purchasing) - [subchapter 5 bankruptcy (1)](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/topic/subchapter-5-bankruptcy) DISCLAIMER: The information in this blog post (“post”) is provided for general informational purposes only, and may not reflect the current law in your jurisdiction. By visiting this website, blog, or post you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Goosmann Law Firm attorneys and website publisher. No information contained in this post should be construed as legal advice from Goosmann Law Firm, PLC, or the individual author, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader of this post should act or refrain from acting on the basis of any information included in, or accessible through, this Post without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from a lawyer licensed in the recipient’s state, country or other appropriate licensing jurisdiction. #### Let Us Know What You Thought about this Post. Put your Comment Below. [Previous Post](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/water-the-most-important-collateral-lenders-overlook) ##### [Water - The Most Important Collateral Lenders Overlook](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/water-the-most-important-collateral-lenders-overlook) [Next Post](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/10th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-tyson-finds-private-educational-loans-are-not-automatically-nondischargeable) ##### [10th Circuit Bankruptcy Judge Tyson Finds Private Educational Loans Are Not Automatically Nondischargeable](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/banking-lawyer-on-you-side/10th-circuit-bankruptcy-judge-tyson-finds-private-educational-loans-are-not-automatically-nondischargeable) ### Contact Info **Sioux City Location** P. 712-226-4000 F. (712) 224-4517 **Sioux Falls Location** P. (605) 371-2000 F. (605) 275-2039 **Omaha Location** P. (402) 280-7648 F. (402) 505-3967 --- [Disclaimer](http://goosmannlaw.com/list-all-blogs/disclaimer/) | [Privacy Policy](http://goosmannlaw.com/privacy-policy/) ### Locations **Sioux City Location** 410 5th Street Sioux City, IA 51101 **Sioux Falls Location** 5010 S. Minnesota Avenue, Suite 100 Sioux Falls, SD 57108 **Omaha Location** Advent Building 17838 Burke Street, Suite 250 Omaha, NE 68118 ![Goosmann](https://blog.goosmannlaw.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Blog_Images/Lockbox%20Lawyer/goosmann-white.png?width=250&name=goosmann-white.png "Goosmann") Goosmann Law Firm is a FULL SERVICE LAW FIRM with locations in Sioux City, Iowa, Sioux Falls, South Dakota, and Omaha, Nebraska. Goosmann Law attorneys are licensed to practice in Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota, and North Dakota. Their attorney team's practices and industries include but are not limited to Agribusiness and Cooperatives, Banking and Finance, Bankruptcy, Restructuring and Workouts, Business, Construction, Cyber Law and Telecommunications, Divorce and Family Law, Education, Employment, Environmental Health and Safety, Gestational Surrogacy and Adoption, Health Care, Litigation and Trial Law, Manufacturing, Mergers and Acquisitions, Municipal, Nonprofit and Tax Exempt Organizations, Real Estate, and Transportation, Tribal, Wills, Trusts, Estate Planning, and Probate Law. Goosmann © Copyright 2017